Navigating the Craft Beer Debate: When Ordering a Simple IPA Sparks Controversy

Have you ever been in a situation where your beverage choice led to unexpected judgment? I recently experienced one of these moments during a dinner outing with colleagues that brought the topic of beer preferences to the forefront of our conversation.

As the server approached our table, I opted for their house IPA—not because I wanted to make a statement, but simply because I enjoy the complex flavors that craft beers have to offer. To my surprise, my choice prompted a rather condescending reaction from my coworker, who exclaimed, “Wow, you’re really into that craft beer stuff!” It felt as though I had committed a social faux pas, akin to ordering a high-end wine with a casual meal.

This colleague’s reaction quickly devolved into him lamenting the “fancy flavors” that craft beers boast—commenting that all he needs is a “normal beer that tastes like beer.” Ironically, he then chose a Stella, seemingly under the impression that its European origins elevated its status. In that moment, I attempted to clarify that hops are not an outlandish ingredient, but rather an essential component that contributes to the unique profiles of craft beers. However, he remained firmly convinced that anything outside the realm of macro lagers was pretentious.

As I tried to engage in a reasonable discussion about the flavors and craftsmanship involved in brewing, I couldn’t help but notice the irony: he was spending a few extra dollars on a lager that was essentially a more expensive version of the very beers he deemed “normal.” It made me ponder how to navigate these conversations without coming off as a so-called “beer snob.” After all, my intention was never to provoke—merely to enjoy a drink that I’d find flavorful and enjoyable.

Has anyone else faced similar situations where you find yourself defending your beer choices to someone who believes that a twist of lime in a Corona is the pinnacle of adventurous drinking? It’s a perplexing dynamic where simply choosing an IPA can position you as an avowed craft beer advocate in the eyes of those who prefer the comfort of mainstream options.

In the world of craft beer, there’s so much to explore and appreciate. It’s a shame that personal preferences can sometimes spark such polarized opinions. Let’s celebrate the diversity of our choices rather than reduce them to notions of sophistication or pretentiousness. Cheers to enjoying what we love—whether it’s a locally brewed IPA or a classic lager!